
Can't say I loooved it but it was good entertainment.
Premise : Life - even the lowest type - is the best university around. It teachs you a whole lot and you have to pay attention. Love - gives you unbelievable amount of confidence.
How else do you explain the cool assurance with which the slumdog breezes through the game show even as the host is constantly snubbing him and running him down with "The Chaiwala" taunts.
All the kids were outstanding, esp the little ones. All of them very were extremely natural and therefore believable. Yet somehow the movie fails to stike a chord.
Firstly slum kids don't speak english, that too so well. The poverty,filth and hardships were all too matter of fact so you didn't feel bad for the kids, nor could you feel the pain or anguish of the situations they face. C'mon now real India is not just about thieving kids being kicked and beaten. Nor is real America all about innocent compassionate tourists who get fleeced by "real India".
Anil Kapoor was really not good as the game show host. I really didn't think he came across as insincere or anything. Just stilted. The gameshow is shown to be a live telecast show. I always thought "Kaun banega Crorepati" was a recorded show. Or all shows are, for that matter pre-recorded.
Irfan Khan and Saurabh Shukla were good but I really can't believe that the police gives anyone electric shocks to find out if they cheated in a gameshow.
Mahesh Manjrekar- I've seen him do much better.
So many artistic/cinematic licenses have been taken that it cannot be termed a realistic film. Showing poverty, filth and lowlife are not the only qualifications for "realistic cinema". It's like Bollywood queens deglaming, getting into cotton saris and scrubbing their faces of make-up and saying we are doing serious cinema - art!! It's a role of a life time- never mind that it has no substance (role and film).
On the whole the characters seemed lack depth. Some of the lines are good (e.g-I told you it doesn't take a genius to know that one.)but most lack punch. The story line was good, convincing even, yet the story doesn't connect.The drama, the tensions of the slum dog's life just didn't come through. Incidents that left indelible marks on the protogonist's life and gave him the answers to the quizmaster's questions just didn't register an impact on the viewer's(read my)mind.Perhaps a stronger (not louder just stronger)background score would have helped.
All in all it was good but not terrific. I really don't see the need for all the golden globes and oscars.
Special mention for Rehman's music - I looove the song Jai Ho!! and I think so did the rest of the audiance. Nobody got up when they played this song as the credits rolled. No people crowding the aisles or moving towards the door. The entire theatre sat put till the song got over.
Jai Ho
Aaja Aaja Jind Shamiyane Ke Tale
Aaja Jariwale Nile Aasman Ke Tale
Jai Ho Jai Ho
Jai Ho Jai Ho
Ratti Ratti Sachi Maine Jaan Gavayi Hai
Nach Nach Koylo Pe Raat Bitayi Hai
Akhiyon Ki Neend Maine Phoonko Se Uda Di
Neele Tare Se Maine Ungli Jalayi Hai
Aaja Aaja Jind Shamiyane Ke Tale
Aaja Jariwale Nile Aasman Ke Tale
Jai Ho Jai Ho
1 comment:
Two of the kids in the movie were in fact from the slums (and still in the slums). And yes they speak English very well. English, ofcourse, is one of the national languages of India.
Post a Comment