Thursday, March 12, 2009

watch whatcha watchin

Dev-D,
Anurang Kashyap's interpretation of Sarat Chandra Chatterji's 1927 novel Devdas has been widely acclaimed. Frankly, I found it to be a drag.
The movie seeks to explore the darker side of today's youth through its new age interpretation of the story and its lead characters. Paro moves on when she realises Dev is not worth her time or attentions. Dev, unable to accept this moves on to vodka and drugs but finally realizes the error of his ways and goes about redeeming himself. Chanda inexplicably finds hope in the hopeless Dev and starts a new chapter of her life with him. The music is good. The story interpretation is interesting. Yet the film is not gripping.
The characters though easy to identify, lack depth and somehow don't connect emotionally. The pace slow, tedious and barely tolerable. Though the premise is believable, the plot is not thick enough to sustain for 2 and 1/2 hours.


Rating: 2 stars.

Saawariya, on the otherhand is a movie has been panned by critics and the public alike but I loved it.
The song "Jab se tere naina" always reminds me of Tritan and the Star from Neil Gaiman's Stardust now I find the the whole movie reminds me of the world on the other side of the wall.
The strange "Agrabad-like" town where the film is set. The blue night light. The strange characters who dress like yesterday but talk like now. The fiesty lady of the night, the lonely landlady, the old matriarch who staples her young ward to her skirts with a safety pin, the brooding stranger, the happy-go-lucky singer...
If you ignore the plot, which is quite easy as it's barely there, you can easily lose yourself in this magical world. I would not have been suprised in the least if a Faun or a Hobbit or some other enchanted being were shown to be walking down those magical streets.
The music is equally captivating. Loved it all in all.

Rating: 3 stars
The movie loses 2 for weakness of plot and lack of moving performances from the protagonists.

4 comments:

Saumya said...

You've really gone mad!..Delhi 6 ... 5 stars...plsss... wht with the gng to the heaven scene twice...and Sawaariya.. lesser spoken abt it the better...wht was magical about something that was blue and dark with no magic happening.. :):)!!!

Legen------wait for it ------dary said...

I felt like arguing wen U rated dill6 5 stars ...... but said ppl can have their own opinion.... and I might be labeled as "In a state of denial"

then I saw Dev D getting 2 star rating ....... hard but I digested that too ..... cause its not an easy movie on girls and girls have every right to hate it (In a state of denial, of-course)

but the last one Saawariya - loved it all in all!!!!!!!! ......... Definitely you are in a state of denial for good movies and real world ....U need fantasy (Alice in wonderland)….U are one of those rare species who would buy the kaala bunder wala climax …and ofcourse the heaven mein jelebi…. (Icing on the cake)

It’s better off saying “I rest my case” after the Saawariya review
(Thanx but No-thanx)

Hard but please digest this (U pushed me to the limit)- don't wanna piss neone off

Tequila said...

@ brave: perhaps u do get jalebis in heaven...

Anonymous said...

well...i LOVED D6 (focus on the underlying message, and not the 2 minute heaven scene) , i LOVED DevD (but i agree with you that some people may find it to be a drag), and i really liked saawariya.

it seems that we are both either very intelligent or equally stupid